Chula: Trickery - Offizielles Ruling

[ Fragen an Dr. Csont ]

Geschrieben von Jaglom Shrek [Amb] am 01. Januar 2002 04:06:20:

>> 1) Do you add in modifiers? (hand weapons, Lower Decks, etc.)
>
>I would suspect no ("recites their attribute numbers"), but I'd wait for
>a
>more official ruling on that.
>
>> 2) Do you have to recite the numbers in any specific order? (INT,
>> CUN & STR or can you mix them around?) 3) Do you just recite the
>> numbers as they are printed on the card? (In order, from left to right
>> with no modifiers, positive or negative).
>
>I would think that you would have to tell your opponent what
>numbers are associated with what stats, no matter the order. And
>honestly, folks, I'm not looking forward to a CR entry telling people
>that you must read them in X order. :(

Neither am I, but it sure looks like it is going to be necessary.

Here's the ruling, now: "recites their attribute numbers" means "read
them off the card, in order, without modifiers."

"Recite" means "to read aloud publicly" or "to give a list of
something". A list implies order. Reading aloud publicly implies
reading "in order"; if you were asked to recite the Gettysburg
Address, presumably you would be expected to start at the beginning
with "Four score and seven years ago", not say the words in a random
order.

As Allen said before -- it's not a trick question. Being able to list
them in random order would make it essentially impossible to pass
this dilemma with more than one or two people (and *really*
impossible for Borg), which means it might just as well have been
written as "Entire crew or Away Team is 'stopped.' Discard dilemma."
As for modifiers, it would be next to impossible for your opponent to
know exactly what cards should be modifying that personnel; since
it's a random selection, he isn't necessarily going to know what hand
weapons, PADDs, modifying personnel, etc. are in the Away Team.
--

Jolan tru,

Major Rakal
(Kathy McCracken)

Tal Shiar Agent and Star Trek CCG Intelligence Officer
---------------------------------------------------------------------
DECIPHER INC. The Art of Great Games (tm)
---------------------------------------------------------------------
MajorRakal@decipher.com -- Star Trek CCG rules questions
http://www.decipher.com -- Check here for latest news!
CCGCustomerService@decipher.com -- defective cards, info request, etc
---------------------------------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Visit Major Rakal's Tal Shiar Headquarters!
http://members.bellatlantic.net/~vze3bf3i/Rakal.html
(Note new address and change your bookmarks!)

__________---------o---------______
/~~ ____=========/~ ~~~~~~----___
/' // || /' __----~~~~~~~~~~~~\~~~~~~\
/' O~ /'| ]~~|~~~~~~~~~~~~\ ) o|
|//~~~__/'_/ ]__|____________/________________/___ __/
|/~~~/___/========_ \ ______----~~~
| _-~ ~~---------------~~~~~~
`~
---------------------------------------------------------------------



Antworten:

[ Fragen an Dr. Csont ]